Bartlein carbon fiber barrel vs proof The carbon fiber is simply there to add more rigidity without adding much weight. Someone explain it to me that makes sense from a hunter and shooters stand point. Bartlein was awesome but the PROOF is better - smaller groups, less coldbore deviation, less heating and lighter. Their BA barrel have a full covered barrel unlike the AR's having slot cuts. Bartlein, proof, and benchmark obviously use their own blanks. Proof Sendero 26" - 47. They don’t list weights but they say you can take 20%-25% off the same steel contour. I currently have 2 proof carbon barrels that both seem a bit picky, and a bartlein carbon fiber I don't have as much time with. What is everyone’s experiences with those two barrels Aug 21, 2022 · I've had 3. In my experience, that will leave potential accuracy on the table. 5-15. (edit) and yes a big reason for choosing May 15, 2020 · Taking an early look at the new Bartlein Barrel, Carbon Fiber Wrapped Bartlein is the gold standard for precision rifle barrels, and this is their new entry Dec 3, 2021 · dont think you can really go wrong with any of the carbon barrels. Mar 5, 2022 · Bartlein's lightest carbon contour (#4) is basically the same weight as a #3 bartlein steel. 050" even gap looks great, but what I've found is that barrels come and go-- and are the easiest way to make weight come or go so the contour isn't always the same, and it's easier on me if the channels is just hogged out from the get-go, you don't notice misalignment as easily if the gaps are bigger Jan 5, 2019 · Even their carbon fiber barrels have a steel barrel as the liner, and while the steel liner is fairly thin they’d still be safe to fire without the carbon fiber wrap. Everything from hand guns I own a Bartlein carbon fiber barrel because I have had good luck with their regular barrels and my gunsmith told me he sees less issues with Bartlein vs Proof barrels. 5 The extra on the proof is . Enough to do a pressure test, a course and fine seating test, but it has been super consistent so far. 4ozs lighter (based on 24"). Nov 21, 2018 · Well guys I'm thinking about building a rifle using a proof research Barrel but don't know much about carbon fiber barrels if somebody could give me a little bit of insight would be great I'm kind of on the fence. I ended up with a Proof barrel for a few hundred extra dollars, but will give the Carbon 6 a chance next time. Benchmark - They use like a blanket of carbon or something. HOWEVER, the Proof barrel got way hotter to begin with. Almost 90% of these pro-level PRS shooters are running rifles that weigh 20-26 pounds in a “ready to fire” configuration (including optics and other accessories). Unless you’re shooting long strings of fire the heavy profile is only adding mass. 5lbs, Proof Sendero barrel 300 Norma Improved -9. Jan 15, 2019 · I don't know about Bartlein carbon barrels but my guess is this is not normal. PROOF Research Pre-Fit Accuracy International barrels are quick and easy to install on the AI platform and require no specialized gunsmithing. Accuracy is similar in both, steel is half the price. Weight goes to Proof, finish goes Feb 7, 2008 · Proof Research claims their carbon wrap on barrels conducts heat faster than barrel steel. Carbon fiber is a special variation of the Bartlein barrels contours. It is for 20 shots @ 1000 yards, I shot a 200-9X. 224 22” that weighs 52oz If I read right, a PROOF Sendero light 26inch 7mm is going to weigh in at 48oz. Feb 12, 2018 · I just get the stock for MTU or M24 and live with some gap. Bartlein carbon barrels are NOT lightweight. theyve been great. 710" shoulder @ 20" finish length so IMO it would be bad choice to buy a bartlein carbon for that application unless you want to spend $300 more for a barrel with worse performance odds because you think it looks cool. Feb 3, 2014 · A fluted 3B Bartlein will be close in weight to a proof Sendero Light for about 1/2 the cost. 24" 1:7. 223. Bartlein Carbon Fiber on a Dec 15, 2017 · Where the carbon fiber barrels do shine is with PRS (gas gun and bolt) and the various forms of 3-gun competitions using AR platforms. . Aug 17, 2021 · The hard spot for me is that the barrel that I've actually seen first hand reports of having problems is proof carbon barrels. Explore Bartlein's precision craftsmanship that champions performance and championship wins, versus Proof’s innovative lightweight designs favored by hunters and competitive shooters. The guy that builds my match rifles also builds my hunting rifles. Jun 24, 2022 · My 2 Bartlein CFs, while a touch heavier than Proof, are all wicked accurate. I will give the carbon barrels one thing. 2” shank. Proof - I think Proof is the standout in carbon fiber. 044″ +/- . I've also used Xcaliber for a 22-250 AI that's been a hammer. Jun 9, 2009 · My last Bartlein 6mm carbon walks horizontal till it's hot, then after 8-10 shots, shoots lil tiny groups. All have shot very well for me. The weight variation between calibers is negligible. cant decide on whos barrels. For reference I have a fluted Brux #5 . Apr 15, 2017 · If you're actually looking for light weight, ditch the idea of carbon and run a smaller-profile steel barrel. That said, all of the carbon barrel compromises are very good about warranty when their barrels don't shoot. As you turn the contour smaller and smaller in size this can have a negative effect on the bore sizes changing and opening up. Oct 6, 2014 · I have a . 5lbs and Bartlein #13 contour 6. However, would the rigidity increase of a carbon barrel in an MTU profile/proof sendero (3 pounds?) play into a reduced impact shift over consistent firing compared to a steel barrel at 3 pounds (approx #2 depending on who made it)? Nov 25, 2019 · I know proof barrels would satisfy that but I don’t think I want carbon fiber. will be 30 cals, 24-26, 1:8/1:9. May 7, 2022 · Their roots are a steel barrel company and are just coming into carbon barrels. After a detailed Q&A session, he asked me how deep the flutes were and said if they were more than xx thousanths deep they couldn't warrant the barrel. TIA! Aug 27, 2019 · Need some help deciding between the 22" Proof Carbon Fiber Camgas and the Craddock Precision Bartlein. Beautiful finish Dec 15, 2021 · The Bartlein barrel sounds interesting. A good smith will spend more time on quality setup to indicate the barrel perfectly in the lathe. All have shot really well. No sweat. They shoot great, just as good as a traditional steel barrel. As for "lightweight" actions, I like the Kelbly Nanook in an all-steel action. Would love your thoughts! Thank you! Nov 12, 2020 · My 2 Bartlein CFs, while a touch heavier than Proof, are all wicked accurate. carbon6 really makes me nervous. These are cut with a Bentz chamber, and headspace at . If they are doing something like Proof then that’s the real competition for Proof. Almost all barrels these days are cut on CNC lathes with excellent repeatability, you'll get the same from Proof or a smith. Bartleins usually run $700 to $745, Proof runs $779 - $799 but are on sale on occasion. 5lbs; weight includes rifle and optics). My most accurate rifle has a steel Bartlein barrel on it, they do great work and I bet they'd agree this isn't normal. If I was going with another carbon barrel though it would be the M24 Bartlein carbon wrapped barrel. Dec 15, 2017 · 26 inch barrel I'm thinking a fluted bartlein sendero contour is going to run around 3. Available contours are their #4 Bull Sporter, #13 Remington Varmint/Sendero, and the #14 M24/M40. 001″ (depending on your action). The proof has 1. I feel like I've never really hear any bad mouth Bartiein, even in the trash heap known as the internet review world. Is there a higher chance of getting a lemon? Mar 14, 2012 · I've seen these rifles print group after group that we just shake our heads. I just ordered new barrel for my 6. A #3 bartlein should have a little over 0. I grabbed a Proof Barrel AI Pre-Fit that matched my barrel pretty darn close and compared the weight They were much closer when compared this way, pre-chambering the Bartlein was about 1LBS heavier, post chambering it was much closer. Our drop-in barrels for the AI chassis come threaded and chambered in a variety of different lengths and twist rates. I almost purchased a Carbon 6 barrel in September during one of their sales but couldn't find many glowing reviews. The 10% of fiber wrapped barrels are lousy mentioned above has been repeated by some pretty knowledgeable folks on this forum too. Having trouble deciding between a proof stainless or bartlein in that contour. Conversely, 90%+ of good quality steel barrels shoot well. I spoke to the gunsmith that I'm looking to use for some action work and barreling the action. Oct 31, 2019 · I’ll post the article when I get home. 8 lbs, Proof is 3. I have 7 Proof CF barrels too. Heavier than a proof for sure, about the same as the #13 Bartlein CF. May 5, 2020 · Below is the announcement from Bartlein Barrels: It’s been a hard thing to keep under wraps, no pun intended. 338) in CFW. But Bartlein Barrels is now offering Carbon wrapped barrels!! We have been helping test these for a few months now and all I can say is they are very impressive. Will likely always go PROOF. 1- I don't see any weight savings 2- Steel barrels shoot just as good and maintain consistency longer 3 At this time, no other options are available for Carbon Fiber Wrapped Barrels. Everything from hand guns I am still looking for the MRP-L MLOK 13. " It's also common to see facts recited about thermal conductivity of carbon fiber, causing many to believe carbon fiber around a barrel acts as an insulator, holding heat in. Hells canyon use(d) Rock and Benchmark blanks and did the carbon wrapping, not sure what their current practice is. X brand may be button pulled or pushed etc but let’s just say for this instance we are choosing a cut rifled barrel. The ONLY advantage of it over steel that was a consideration for me was the weight savings. It appears Patriot Valley arms threaded the barrel and fit the muzzle brake against the carbon fiber but I need to take it apart and look closer. 750" taperless and both shoot excellent. I've had a Bartlein barrel before that was crazy accurate in 300WM. Apr 30, 2020 · I picked up my Bartlein Wrapped Carbon Fiber Barrel, after being chambered and threaded. Feb 28, 2011 · Both make great barrels. Everything from hand guns Jun 15, 2024 · Carbon Fiber . Nov 4, 2020 · I have Proof and Hells Canyon Carbon barrels and have shot some others. Please see the below table for CFW weights. A smaller profile steel weighs very similar to a carbon wrap, in some cases even less. Feb 16, 2017 · Small frame, current plan is 5. Jan 26, 2022 · A Proof is definitely cheaper than a carbon wrapped Bartlein. Simply thread it on, torque it down, double check headspace and head for the range. Proof Research: 6 ARC Carbon Fiber AR Barrel, 1 -7. 180 degrees vs 150-something for the unfluted and 160-something for the fluted. Oct 22, 2021 · A Bartlein or Kreiger barrel blank is probably ever so slightly better on average than a Proof barrel blank. All the engineering based material heat transfer tables show carbon fiber heat transfer rates are slower than steel transfer rates May 19, 2014 · ^^Exactly as above this time around because of wait time I chose Bartlein. I paid $700 for both of my Barts. Given how #3s shoot sustained, in my experience they make for great precision/hunters. I'll hand it to proof, they replaced the barrel no questions asked and this one shoots as well if not a little better than the Bartlein. While the Carbon Fiber barrel is nothing new, Bartlein is jumping into the market and bringing their expert barrel making knowledge and legendary reputation. For the same diameter, Proof offers a carbon fiber-wrapped alternative that drops some weight without sacrificing precision -- per Norm Crawford (retired Delta sergeant major, Palma shooter, and long-range Camp Perry National Champion whose M14 record still stands). xrne zupz zhfgxcfn okvb fxdlfly fuq opbpof bethu gzvz stedov njco dknj wesw znbi vxrsd
powered by ezTaskTitanium TM